'Morning-After'
Pill Available at Some Department of Defense Clinics
By Lawrence Morahan
CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer
June 03, 2002
(Washington,
DC) - The Pentagon is coming under fire for making available to female
soldiers the so-called "morning-after" pill, a controversial
drug that is usually taken after unprotected sex to prevent pregnancy.
The
drug, known as Plan B, prevents a fertilized ovum from implanting itself
in the uterus by changing the lining. Rape victims who wanted to prevent
pregnancy have used it for some time at military facilities, a Pentagon
spokesman said.
The
drug is not carried at all of the Pentagon's 76 military hospitals and
500-plus health clinics worldwide, nor is it part of "the basic
core formulary," which mandates the drugs that all medical facilities
must stock.
"It's
basically up to the individual pharmacy, and it's not just the Army,
it's a DoD policy that's been in use for years," Army Maj. Steve
Stover said.
The
Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved Plan B, or levonorgestrel,
in July 1999. The drug, which prevents conception if taken up to 72
hours after sex, is sometimes confused with RU-486, which causes spontaneous
abortions in early pregnancy, and which is not carried at any of the
Defense Department's medical treatment facilities.
However,
family groups said levonorgestrel acts as an abortifacient and should
not be distributed at military medical facilities, which ban abortions.
"As
far as we're concerned it causes an abortion to take place. It kills
a human embryo," said Robert Maginnis, vice president of the Family
Research Council and a retired Army colonel.
The
prohibition against abortion at military facilities should include chemical
abortion, whether it's one day after the sex act or months afterward,
Maginnis said.
"The
time is inconsequential because it's a human being in our viewpoint
that's being killed here, and the Defense Department should not be in
the business of killing innocent human beings, whether on the battlefield
in Afghanistan or in hospitals," he said.
Wendy
Wright, communications director for Concerned Women for America, said
dispensing the drug at military medical facilities could have the effect
of encouraging illicit sexual activity among people in the armed forces.
"That
breaks down morale, it breaks down discipline and it's activity that
the military should be explicitly trying to prevent, not facilitate,"
she said.
Schools
also are coming under fire for dispensing morning-after pills to students.
In
April 2000, over 180 schools across the country were offering the morning-after
pill at school-based clinics to girls as young as 13 and 14, and this
without their parents' permission or knowledge, said Brendan Benner,
communications director for Rep. Melissa Hart (R-Pa.), citing statistics
released by the Congressional Research Service.
Hart
recently introduced legislation through the Education Committee that
seeks to block federal funding from public schools that provide the
medication.
"It's
essentially saying, if you give this out, you're going to lose your
federal funding," Benner said.
Judie
Brown, president of the American Life League, said the high doses of
hormones in morning-after pills present a danger to girls who are not
fully grown and to women suffering from high blood pressure, or who
have a history in their families of breast cancer.
"No
one is going to know whether or not they have contributed to the early
death of one of these women because no one is collecting any of this
kind of information," she said.
Abortion
rights advocates say that Plan B is not an abortifacient, arguing that
the medical definition of pregnancy is when a fertilized egg attaches
to the uterus.
The
National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL), a proponent
of emergency contraception, did not return calls seeking comment.
However,
a statement on its website said much of the opposition to emergency
contraceptive pills (ECPs) "arises from the mistaken belief that
ECPs cause abortion. ECPs, however, do not disrupt an established pregnancy,
which begins with implantation of the fertilized egg in the uterine
lining."
"Rather,
ECPs delay or inhibit ovulation or implantation prior to pregnancy and
therefore, do not cause abortion," it said.
NARAL
also said hospitals should provide emergency contraception to rape survivors.
"Emergency
contraception is a safe and effective method to prevent unwanted pregnancy.
It also can empower women who have been raped with a sense of control
and provide an important way to help them to cope with the trauma of
sexual assault," the group said.
Advocates
are pushing the FDA to allow morning-after pills to be sold over the
counter. In Alaska, California and Washington, women can get morning-after
pills directly from pharmacists who are authorized to dispense prescription
drugs without having to see their doctor.
The
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists has urged its members
to offer prescriptions for emergency contraception during patients'
regular checkups.
|