Bush:
'Life Is A Creation, Not A Commodity'
By Melanie Hunter
CNSNews.com Evening Editor
April 10, 2002
(CNSNews.com)
- President Bush Wednesday urged the Senate to approve legislation for
a total ban on human cloning. Speaking at the White House, the president
said anything less than a total ban would be "unethical."
Supporters
of human cloning say research could provide cures for diseases like
diabetes, Alzheimer's and paralysis.
But "the
most noble ends do not justify any means," Bush said. "Advances
in biomedical technology must never come at the expense of human conscience."
He pointed
out that Chinese scientists "have derived stem cells from cloned
embryos created by combining human DNA and rabbit eggs. Others have
announced plans to produce cloned children, despite the fact that laboratory
cloning of lab animals have led to spontaneous abortion and terrible,
terrible abnormalities."
"Human
cloning is deeply troubling to me and to most Americans. Life is a creation,
not a commodity," Bush said. "Our children are gifts to be
loved and protected, not products to be designed and manufactured."
The president
said allowing research cloning, "while forbidding the birth of
a human child," would lead to the destruction of human life, and
allowing cloning for research only - even with restrictions - would
be "virtually impossible to enforce."
"Once
cloned embryos are available implantation would take place. Even the
tightest regulations and [strict] policing would not prevent or detect
the birth of cloned babies," Bush said, adding that "the benefits
of research cloning are highly speculative."
Evidence
shows, he said, that cells derived from cloned embryos might be rejected.
"Yet
even if research cloning were medically effective, every person who
wanted to benefit would need an embryonic clone of his or her own to
provide the designer tissues. This would create a massive national market
for eggs and egg donors and exploitation of women's bodies that we cannot
and must not allow," Bush said to a round of applause.
He expressed
faith in the benefits of adult stem cell research and referred to his
announcement last year on embryonic stem cell research on a limited
number of existing stem cell lines.
"This
year for the first time federal dollars will go towards supporting human
embryonic stem cell research consistent with the ethical guidelines
I announced last August," the president said. "Adult stem
cells that do not require the destruction of human embryos, and which
yield tissues that can be transplanted without rejection, are more versatile
than originally thought."
Sen. Bill
Frist (R-Tenn.), a heart surgeon and the only medical doctor in the
United States Senate, informed his Senate colleagues last night of his
support for a cloning ban. Frist's and the president's stance on cloning
received applause from the Concerned Women for America, the nation's
largest public policy women's organization.
"Thank
God for President Bush and Sen. Frist who have the patience to remind
us that we are not gods. Even if we have the power to create human life,
we do not have the right to destroy it for utilitarian purposes,"
CWA President Sandy Rios said in a statement Wednesday.
The American
Center for Law and Justice, an international public interest law firm,
also praised the president.
"This
is a tremendously important opportunity to protect human life,"
said Jay Sekulow, Chief Counsel of the ACLJ, who attended a White House
meeting on cloning.
"A total
ban on human cloning is not only the correct decision from a political
standpoint, it is essential to the preservation of human life. While
there is tremendous support for advancements in medical science, such
progress should never occur at the expense - and destruction - of human
life," Sekulow added.
"The
president's decision to elevate the cloning issue in this manner underscores
his commitment to life. And, we're hopeful this high profile push will
break the logjam on this issue in the Senate," he said.
|