Senate
Battle Looms Over Embryonic Cloning
By Christine Hall
CNSNews.com Staff Writer
March 05, 2002
(CNSNews.com)
- Both sides in the human embryo cloning debate turned up the volume
of their rhetoric Tuesday in anticipation of a Senate vote on the issue
later this month or in April.
Christopher
Reeve, the actor who once played Superman, but was later paralyzed below
the neck in an equestrian accident, warned that if the government refuses
to fund and provide oversight for embryonic cloning, "it will happen
privately, dangerously unregulated and controlled."
Supporters
of so-called therapeutic cloning argue it has the potential for producing
stem cells that could yield major scientific breakthroughs in curing
human diseases. Opponents contend it's unethical to create human embryos
either for reproductive purposes or for the purpose of destroying them
for research.
Senate Majority
Leader Thomas Daschle (D-S.D.) promised Sen. Sam Brownback (R-Kan.),
a leading opponent of embryonic cloning, that Senate debate on the issue
would begin in February or March. But with only 13 days left on the
legislative calendar in March, it may be delayed until April.
Tuesday,
Reeve joined supporters of embryonic cloning in testifying before a
Senate panel chaired by Sen. Ted Kennedy of Massachusetts. Reeve said
the extraction of stem cells from cloned human embryos would not lead
to embryo farms, as opponents have warned.
"That's
nonsense, because we will be able to regulate what happens," Reeve
said at a news conference prior to the hearing.
Because so-called
therapeutic cloning does not require fertilization of an egg, like normal
human reproduction, it is not a process that destroys human life, Reeve
said.
"If
we don't make this research legal, if we don't use government funding
and oversight, it will happen privately, dangerously unregulated and
controlled," Reeve said, adding that the U.S. would "lose
its preeminence in science and medicine."
Brownback
and Democratic Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisiana have introduced a bill
to ban embryonic cloning. During a separate news conference, Landrieu
warned that human cloning will "[turn] the miracle of birth into
a manufacturing process" and lead to the exploitation of women
who will be tempted to sell their eggs for money.
The "human
body is not a product to be mass produced and stripped in parts,"
said Landrieu, who also testified at the hearing chaired by Kennedy.
Landrieu
and Brownback stressed that their bill does not preclude other types
of research, including embryonic stem cell research or the (non-embryonic)
cloning of human tissues.
"Momentum
is continuing to grow behind the bipartisan bill, which currently has
23 co-sponsors," said Brownback of the bill he and Landrieu are
co-sponsoring (S. 1899). "A broad coalition of groups on the left,
in the middle and on the right ... support a ban on human cloning."
Senators
Tom Harkin (D-Iowa), Barbara Boxer (D-Calif.), Harry Reid (D-Nev.) and
Arlen Specter (R-Pa.) have a competing bill, S. 1893, that would allow
embryonic cloning but would impose criminal and civil penalties for
anyone who tried to clone a human being for reproductive purposes.
The House
passed a ban on human cloning last year.
|