States
Providing the Lead on Cloning Bans
By Christine Hall
CNSNews.com Staff Writer
February 25, 2002
(CNSNews.com)
- While Congress continues to debate the costs and benefits of a ban
on human cloning, some states are forging ahead with their own laws
banning or restricting the practice.
Proponents
of human cloning argue that harvesting the cells of cloned embryos could
potentially yield cures to human diseases, such as cancer or diabetes.
Opponents contend it's ethically wrong to clone human beings for "spare
parts."
While the
federal government is deadlocked on the issue, "the states are
critically important" in the movement to ban human cloning, according
to William Saunders, senior fellow for human life studies at the Family
Research Council.
By the count
of Richard Doerflinger, an official of the United States Conference
of Catholic Bishops, five states already have laws on the books that
restrict or ban human cloning: Michigan, Virginia, California, Rhode
Island and Louisiana.
On Feb. 21,
a committee of the Colorado House of Representatives approved a bill
to make the cloning of human tissue a felony. Similarly, in Oklahoma,
a committee approved a bill on Feb. 18 that would ban human cloning.
The Oklahoma bill, however, would allow certain exceptions for so-called
therapeutic cloning-cloning not intended for human reproduction.
The bill's
sponsor, Democratic state Rep. Opio Toure said his bill is designed
to prevent the harvesting of human embryos while permitting the cloning
of molecules, DNA and cells for medical research.
Reflecting
the divisive nature of the cloning and stem cell research debate, Republican
state Rep. Bill Graves blasted the bill for not going far enough. "I
think it's a bad step, a step in the wrong direction if you want to
ban cloning," said Graves, who is sponsoring a tougher anti-cloning
bill.
Other states
have such efforts under way. The South Dakota state Senate last Thursday
approved in a 31-1 vote a resolution urging the federal government to
ban human cloning, expressing the sense of the Senate that cloning embryos
for research shows a lack of respect for the dignity of that person.
Iowa state
Sen. John Redwine hopes to win support for his bill prohibiting human
cloning for any purpose, including stem cell research. Redwine's bill
has opposition from the University of Iowa, an advocate for stem cell
research.
In New Hampshire,
a House committee heard testimony on Feb. 20 about a bill that would
also ban all human cloning in the state. The bill would punish violators
with a fine of up to $1 million or an amount double the financial gain
of such an endeavor.
Some pro-life
activists are calling human cloning, whether for reproductive or therapeutic
purposes, the most critical social issue of our time. At a Capitol Hill
forum on Friday, Doerflinger warned against a future in which cloned
humans are viewed as "mere research material" that is "better
dead than alive."
|