Pro-Life
Victory As Philippines Bans 'Morning-After Pill'
By Patrick Goodenough
CNSNews.com Pacific Rim Bureau Chief
January 08, 2002
Pacific Rim
Bureau (CNSNews.com) - Pro-lifers in the Philippines have succeeded
in having their government outlaw the "morning-after pill"
on the grounds that it can cause an abortion, making it the second country
in five months to impose such a ban.
Anyone who
imports, sells or uses the drug now faces stiff penalties and prosecution.
A pro-life,
pro-family lobby called Abaypamilya (Family Front) last May challenged
the government about the drug Postinor, the trade name under which levonorgestrel
has been marketed in the Philippines since April 2000 as an "emergency
contraceptive."
The campaigners
argued that Postinor was an abortifacient on the grounds that it can
prevent the implantation of a fertilized egg. As such, its promotion
and use violated the country's constitutional protection of life from
the moment of conception.
Abaypamilya
campaigner and lawyer Jo Imbong said by phone from Manila Tuesday that
the complaint had led to a lengthy review by the Bureau of Food and
Drugs, during which written submissions were obtained from a number
of sources.
Among submissions
considered were those from two American experts, bioethicist Dr. Dianne
Irving and internal medicine specialist Dr. Chris Kahlenborn.
Leading Philippine
medical bodies had also provided submissions, as had pharmaceutical
bodies and companies - including the local licensee for Postinor, Schwarz
Pharma.
Apart from
Schwarz Pharma's, all the other submissions agreed that human life begins
from the moment of fertilization - not at the point of implantation
of the ovum into the womb, as argued by promoters of the "morning-after
pill." By preventing implantation of the already fertilized ovum,
the experts said, the drug was acting as an abortifacient.
Last October,
the director of the Bureau of Food and Drugs, William Torres, "came
out with a finding in our favor," Imbong said.
No immediate
action was taken, however, as the Bureau decision had to be approved
by Health Secretary Manuel Dayrit. But the weeks passed without further
action, she said. "Meanwhile, the drug was still legal, women were
using it, and lives were being lost."
Eventually,
her organization had given Dayrit an ultimatum, pointing out the severe
potential legal consequences of not acting to stop the importation of
mislabeled drugs.
Following
this "veiled threat," she said, Dayrit last month finally
approved a Bureau of Food and Drugs circular which cancelled the certificate
of registration for Postinor, prohibited its further importation, sale
and use in the country.
"The
Bureau, after careful and thorough evaluation of the position papers
and researches ... has determined with the concurrence of the Secretary
of Health that Postinor has abortifacient effect and contravenes existing
provisions of law on the matter," the circular says.
Anyone who
continues to import, sell or prescribe the drug in the Philippines will
now face penalties and criminal charges, Imbong said.
As far as
she knows, the Philippines is now the only country in Asia to have banned
the "morning-after pill." Last August, Chile's Supreme Court
outlawed the pill there despite its earlier approval by the health ministry.
Battle ahead
As "euphoric"
as the Philippine campaigners were about the victory, they were also
well aware that "de-population advocates" would not take the
decision lying down, Imbong said.
"The
country will be under pressure [from bodies like the U.N., international
funding agencies and the International Planned Parenthood Federation],"
she predicted. "This is just the beginning."
The Canadian
pro-life campaign, Lifesite, says the Consortium for Emergency Contraception,
a grouping of "abortion supporters" including key U.N. agencies
and non-governmental organizations, is engaged in a campaign to promote
the "morning-after pill" in the developing world.
Pro-lifers
point to a Dec. 2000 decision by a major Muslim organization in Indonesia
to collaborate with those promoting the "morning-after pill."
It was reported at the time that the organization, Muhammadiyah, had
been persuaded that the drug did not go against the teachings of Islam.
The Consortium
for Emergency Contraception says on its website that its local representatives
in Indonesia had "helped set the stage for an eventual product
introduction," having established "a successful relationship
with a key Islamic organization with service delivery potential and
influence on the registration decision."
Imbong said
that there were government and non-governmental elements in the predominantly
Roman Catholic Philippines who colluded with foreign pro-abortion advocates.
Although
the Philippines' 1987 constitution expressly protects the life of the
unborn from the moment of conception, pro-life positions were under
attack, she said.
Imbong praised
international pro-life cooperation, saying her group was especially
indebted to groups like the American Life League and Pharmacists for
Life.
The pro-life
achievement in the Philippines comes at a time campaigners in Britain
are fighting both a legal action to restrict availability of the "morning-after
pill," and attempts by an advertising watchdog to challenge its
assertion that the drug can cause abortions.
Two Catholic
publications in Britain recently said they would continue to run ads
by the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child (SPUC). The ads
describe the drug as an abortifacient, despite a call by the Advertising
Standards Authority for publishers not to do so.
SPUC has
welcomed the news from the Philippines, saying it "congratulated
all those involved in the campaign against the drug" there.
|