ACLJ
Files Religious Discrimination Complaint With EEOC Against Louisiana
Health Dept. Over "Morning-After" Pill
October 23, 2002
(New
Orleans, LA) - The American Center for Law and Justice, an
international public interest law firm committed to protecting
life, today announced it is representing a nurse from Louisiana
who has been threatened with termination for refusing to dispense
pregnancy-ending medication - a requirement that violates
her deeply held religious beliefs. The ACLJ has filed a formal
complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission
(EEOC) and the Louisiana Commission on Human Rights contending
that the employer - Louisiana Dept. of Health and Hospitals
- is discriminating against the nurse because of her religious
beliefs.
"This
is a case where a nurse is facing religious discrimination
because her deeply held beliefs do not permit her to dispense
medication designed to end pregnancies," said Stuart
J. Roth, Senior Counsel of the ACLJ, which is representing
the health care worker.
"Our client just wants to do her job without violating
her conscience and her religious beliefs. Instead of accommodating
this employee, health department officials have decided to
criticize her and threaten her with termination. We will do
whatever it takes to protect the conscience rights of our
client."
The
ACLJ filed the complaints this week with the EEOC and the
Louisiana Commission on Human Rights on behalf of Cynthia
Day of Marrero, Louisiana who is employed as a Public Health
Nurse III with the Louisiana Department of Health and Hospitals,
Office of Public Health at a clinic in New Orleans.
The
complaints contend that Day repeatedly told her supervisors
that she could not dispense what is known as an emergency
contraception pill, also known as a "morning-after"
pill - medication designed to end pregnancies. Day says she
holds a sincere religious belief that human life, beginning
at fertilization, is sacred and cannot be harmed in any way.
Day contends that she has been criticized for her beliefs,
threatened with being fired, and transferred to a job that
makes it much more likely that she will have to dispense the
objectionable medication to patients.
"The
state must accommodate the sincerely held religious beliefs
of our client," said Roth. "There is no question
that the health department could have another employee dispense
the medication instead of our client. But, health department
officials have not only rejected our request to accommodate
our client's religious beliefs, they continue to threaten
and intimidate this health care professional in a manner that
is both unprofessional and unlawful."
Roth
said the ACLJ was required to file formal complaints first
with the EEOC and the Louisiana Commission on Human Rights
before proceeding with filing a lawsuit against the health
department. Roth said the ACLJ is prepared to take legal action
to protect the conscience rights of Day.
In
May 2002, the ACLJ successfully convinced a California jury
that Riverside County violated the constitutional rights of
a former nurse who was fired from her job for refusing to
dispense "morning-after" medication. A federal court
jury found that the county violated her First Amendment rights
of free speech, freedom of religion, and failed to reasonably
accommodate her religious beliefs. Damages in that case -
including a jury award and attorney's fees - totaled $100,000.
The
American Center for Law and Justice is an international public
interest law firm specializing in constitutional law and protecting
human life. The ACLJ is headquartered in Virginia Beach, VA
and its web site address is www.aclj.org.