Pro-Lifers
Push Congress to Pass Unborn Victims of Violence Act
By Jim Burns
CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer
July 02, 2001
Charlotte,
N.C. (CNSNews.com) - The legislative director of the National
Right To Life Committee said Saturday delegates should pressure
their lawmakers to pass the "Unborn Victims of Violence
Act."
The
House approved the legislation in April, but it is still pending
in the Senate, where a similar bill died last year.
Failure
to recognize unborn babies as victims under federal law has
led to a number of cases where justice could not be served,
according to Douglas Johnson, the NRLC's legislative director.
The
Unborn Victims of Violence Act says that when a criminal commits
a federal crime against a pregnant woman and injures or kills
her unborn child, the criminal has claimed two victims. Proponents
say it does not interfere with the Roe vs. Wade Supreme Court
decision that legalized abortion in 1973.
"The
Unborn Victims of Violence Act creates no new federal crimes.
Rather, the bill would come into play only when federal authorities
have cause to arrest someone for an offense against a woman
in an already defined federal crime of violence. It would
also allow them to bring a second charge if there has been
a second victim, an unborn child," Johnson told delegate
at the NRLC's annual convention in Charlotte.
Johnson
criticized the Planned Parenthood Foundation for saying that
"nowhere in the bill is harm against women mentioned."
He called that statement "blatantly misleading"
saying, "The bill really mentions harm against women
68 times, as it cites the 68 federal crimes of violence against
women."
Planned
Parenthood, according to a position paper on its website,
considers the legislation a "federal feticide bill"
that "elevates the status of the fetus at all stages
of development to that of the pregnant woman."
Two
dozen states have laws regarding unborn victims of violence,
according to Johnson.
"This
bill is not a substitute for state laws. It does not supersede
the state laws. States that don't have unborn-victim laws
still need to pass them," Johnson said.
However,
Rep. Zoe Lofgren (D-Calif.), a member of the House Judiciary
Committee, called the bill a "thinly veiled attempt to
legislatively overturn Roe v. Wade."
"The
bill's definition of 'in utero' makes a two-celled fertilized
egg (zygote) a person. Not only is this constitutionally questionable,
it causes the legislation to get mired in the abortion debate,"
Lofgren said.
Lofgren
introduced an amendment to the Unborn Victims of Violence
Act called the "Motherhood Protection Act". It was
defeated by the full House.
|