Would-Be
Human Cloners Press On Despite Opposition
By Patrick Goodenough
CNSNews.com Pacific Rim Bureau Chief
July 26, 2002
Pacific Rim
Bureau (CNSNews.com) - Maverick scientists involved in the race to be
first to clone a human being shrugged off opposition from the South
Korean government, saying there was no legal impediment to their work
in the country.
BioFusion
Tech, the Korean branch of the U.S.-based group, Clonaid, claimed this
week that it has helped a woman become pregnant with a cloned baby.
BioFusion-Clonaid
spokesman Kwak Gi-Hwa said in an interview Friday the "surrogate
mother" was a 26-year-old, unmarried Korean.
The cloned
embryo had been implanted into her womb outside South Korea, he said,
but he refused to say in which country - or even which continent - the
procedure had taken place.
Kwak said
the baby was due to be born in about six months' time. This could occur
either in Korea, he said, "or in Japan or the U.S. or Britain or
Canada or Israel."
The woman
was one of a small group chosen from a pool of 50 volunteers, he said.
They had been selected on grounds of health and mental attitude.
After BioFusion-Clonaid
made its announcement this week, the Korean's health and welfare ministry
said it would be investigating the claim.
Although
human cloning is not yet illegal in Korea, a ministry spokesman said
it was nonetheless unethical. The ministry was investigating whether
any existing laws had been broken, he said.
Kwak said
he was unconcerned about the ministry's stance as the group had broken
no Korean law. No government official had yet visited, he said, although
he had received a phone call.
Korea's JoongAng
Ilbo daily in an editorial urged lawmakers quickly to legislate to outlaw
cloning, which it said went "against the universal belief in the
respect for life."
"Even
if one is skeptical of this particular announcement, it is still a wake-up
call to put into law a set of cell-cloning guidelines" drawn up
by government ministries, it said.
Legislation
outlawing human cloning has been drafted but has some way to go before
passage.
Earlier this
month, Clonaid representative Thomas Kaenzig was quoted as saying in
Tokyo the group felt Asian societies were "more open to new technologies"
while "conservative Christian groups" and other in the West
were strongly opposed.
Clonaid head
Dr. Brigitte Boisselier is one of three controversial scientists who
last year announced their intention to pioneer human cloning. The other
two are Kentucky-based Dr. Panos Zavos and an Italian infertility specialist,
Dr. Severino Antinori.
Antinori
recently told European media organizations he was overseeing three clone
pregnancies. One had successfully passed its first trimester, and that
the baby would be born in December, he said.
Zavos, too,
claims to have selected six couples to produce cloned babies in an unnamed
developing country.
No proof
of any of the claims has been produced.
'Eternal
life'
The idea
of cloning a human being is anathema to many - pro-lifers, ethicists,
environmentalists, medical experts and adherents of most religious groups.
The major
concerns relate to the risks involved - animal cloners have reported
a high failure rate and potential birth defects - as well as to the
ethical questions of experimenting with human embryos and trying to
create "copies" of unique human beings.
The would-be
cloners argue that the technology, once mastered, offers the promise
of genetic offspring to infertile couples, single people and homosexuals.
All efforts
to bring a cloned baby into the world are highly controversial, but
Clonaid's campaign is arguably more so because the group is attached
to an extraterrestrial-worshipping religious cult founded by a former
French journalist, Claude Vorilhon, who calls himself Rael.
Kwak confirmed
Friday that he was himself a Raelian, and believed Rael's teaching that
cloning offered humankind eternal life.
"We
can see every day in the newspapers bad news ... wars everywhere. Cloning
technology can save all life and all human beings can live forever by
this technology," Kwak said.
Asked to
elaborate, he said the Raelians hoped in the future to be able to transfer
a copy of a person's "memories, knowledge and personality"
onto his or her clone.
He conceded
that such technology was not available, but said researchers in the
U.S. and Japan were working on it.
To the argument
that a cloned person would have a soul of his or her own - thus calling
into question the idea that cloning yourself would be a way of achieving
"eternal life" - Kwak replied that Raelians did not believe
humans had "souls and spirits."
Kwak said
it was not necessary for the cloning volunteers to join the Raelians.
The pregnant Korean woman was not a member, he added.
The Raelians
claim to have 55,000 followers in 84 countries. Their leader teaches
that life on earth was created by an extraterrestrial race called "Elohim"
which was mistranslated in the Bible as God. (Elohim is Hebrew for God.)
Rael also
teaches that Jesus was resurrected through a cloning technique. The
group's website says Rael is available for public speeches about cloning,
for a fee of $100,000.
|