Court
Rules Woman May Use Deadly Force to Defend Unborn
By Lawrence Morahan
CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer
October 25, 2002
(CNSNews.com)
- A Michigan appeals court made an accurate interpretation
of the state Legislature's intent when it ruled that a pregnant
woman may use deadly force to protect a fetus from attack,
even if her own life is not in danger, a pro-life group said.
"We
agree with the decision," said Douglas Johnson, legislative
director of the National Right to Life Committee (NRLC). "We
think that the unborn child should be recognized as a full
member of the human family."
Johnson's
comments concerned a case in which the Michigan Court of Appeals
reversed a Kalamazoo County Circuit Court's conviction of
a woman for killing her boyfriend.
Jaclyn
Louise Kurr was convicted of voluntary manslaughter in the
stabbing death of Antonio Pena, on Oct. 9, 1999. She was sentenced
to five to 20 years in prison.
Kurr,
who said she was 16 weeks pregnant with quadruplets at the
time of the incident, testified she was defending herself
during a fight in which Pena punched her in the stomach.
Under
Michigan law, people may use lethal force to defend themselves
when they have reason to believe their lives are in danger,
or when they use deadly force "in defense of others."
However,
at Kurr's trial, Circuit Court Judge Richard Lamb ruled that
the defendant could not use the "defense of others"
argument because the fetuses were not "living human being[s]
existing independent" of the defendant.
Referring
to the 1973 Supreme Court Roe v. Wade decision, which said
a fetus must be at least 22 gestational weeks of age to be
viable outside the womb, Lamb said "even under the evidence
in this case, under 22 weeks, there are no others," a
reference to the defense of others argument.
Kurr
then argued she was acting in self-defense when she stabbed
Pena. The jury rejected this argument and found her guilty
of manslaughter.
The
State of Michigan Court of Appeals earlier this month reversed
Kurr's conviction and ordered a new trial.
"We
agree that a defense of others jury instruction was appropriate
here and therefore reverse defendant's conviction and remand
this case for a new trial," the court said in a 3-0 decision.
The
court based its conclusion "primarily on the fetal protection
act adopted by the Legislature in 1998."
Twenty-six
states have homicide laws that recognize unborn victims, NRLC
research shows. Fourteen of those, including Michigan, have
laws that recognize unborn children as victims throughout
all periods of pre-natal development.
Michigan's
law is one of the most comprehensive, providing felony penalties
for actions that cause "aggravated physical injury to
an embryo or fetus."
Twelve
states cover unborn children in homicide laws only during
part of the period of pre-natal development; seven states
have no unborn victim laws, but criminalize acts that terminate
a human pregnancy or cause a miscarriage.
The
appeals court, in its ruling, did not address when a fetus
becomes a person, often a key issue in abortion cases.
"This
issue, however, is not raised by the parties, is not pertinent
to the resolution of the instant case, and does not drive
our ruling today," the court said.
The
court concluded that a mother may defend a fetus from assault
"and may even use deadly force if she honestly and reasonably
believes the fetus to be in danger of imminent death or great
bodily harm."
Some
unborn victim laws have been in effect since the mid-1980s,
Johnson noted. These laws have been subjected to legal attacks,
but none has been struck down on constitutional grounds.
Prosecutors
have said they plan to ask the Michigan Supreme Court to hear
the case. The question of whether the "defense of others"
argument can be used is irrelevant because the right to self-defense
should be considered adequate to protect both pregnant women
and their fetuses, prosecutors told reporters.
Johnson
said the state Supreme Court is under no obligation to hear
the case.
"If
they do, we're confident the court of appeals ruling will
be upheld," he said.
|