House
Tables Bill Targeting Pro-Life Demonstrators
By Jeff Johnson
CNSNews.com Congressional Bureau Chief
September 16, 2002
Capitol Hill
(CNSNews.com) - Peaceful pro-life demonstrators and sidewalk counselors
won a temporary reprieve Thursday from the threat of multi-million dollar
lawsuits by the abortion industry.
CNSNews.com
learned Friday that the U.S. House of Representatives tabled the Bankruptcy
Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (H.R. 333) because of an
unacceptable compromise over an amendment by pro-abortion Sen. Charles
Schumer (D-N.Y.).
Under Schumer's
amendment, pro-life protesters could not seek bankruptcy protection
from lawsuits filed against them by abortion clinics and their supporters
over alleged misconduct.
In the past,
victims of such lawsuits - who typically do not have the resources to
defend themselves - have been able to declare bankruptcy to avoid having
their assets seized.
But opponents
of the Schumer proposal feared abortionists could win default judgments
against pro-lifers, use the provision to keep them from filing bankruptcy,
and then confiscate their assets to cover alleged "damages"
and attorneys' fees, thereby funding abortions with "pro-life money."
A compromise
agreed to by House negotiators on the conference committee working to
meld the House and Senate versions of the bill was initially thought
to have assuaged those fears.
A statement
that, "Nothing in [this amendment] shall be construed to affect
any expressive conduct (including peaceful picketing or other peaceful
demonstration) protected from legal prohibition by the First Amendment
to the Constitution of the United States," was added to the bill.
While the
House negotiators may have accepted the change, their pro-life constituency
apparently did not.
"We
got a defeat with that so-called compromise Schumer language,"
said Jim Backlin, director of legislative affairs for the Christian
Coalition of America.
The National
Abortion Rights Action League (NARAL) apparently agreed. It called the
agreement a "major victory" and praised Schumer.
"In
the face of some anti-choice lawmakers who resisted holding perpetrators
accountable, he and his colleagues, Senator Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.) and
Joseph Biden (D-Del.), remained steadfast in their determination,"
a NARAL press release stated.
Backlin said
the real goal of the Schumer amendment is to intimidate pro-life individuals
so that they will not offer counseling and literature to women approaching
abortion clinics.
"The
abortion clinics will accomplish their goal of having zero people out
in front of abortion clinics so that their billion dollar business can
continue unabated," he warned.
A "top
Republican House leader" reportedly told Backlin that, "We're
not bringing the bankruptcy bill to the floor until we work this thing
out." Backlin declined to identify that House leader.
Backlin urged
those who support the First Amendment right of pro-life Americans to
speak out, picket, and distribute literature on public sidewalks adjacent
to abortion clinics to pay attention to the bill.
"We
are going to continue to alert our pro-family, pro-life grassroots to
be on the lookout for any kind of floor vote on the bankruptcy bill,"
he warned. "And if we find out that it has any kind of pro-abortion
language, i.e. the Schumer language, in it we will mobilize the troops
to defeat it."
|